Here's how I have my box set-up. It has to be very, very close to the correct way, as I have found a place the fits each piece, for the most part.

The first layer: Top left has the 2 LOS markers and 2 small border pieces, along with the big room tile. Moving right, I have the cards in the next space. And in the top right (top) all the 2-space tiles fit standing up, and (bottom) all the single space tiles fit standing up. Bottom left has the 9-space square tiles, next you can see some of the order tiles in two stacks (they meet flush with the expanded area) and below the order tiles are the 8-space rectangular tiles. The 4-space square tiles are next. The next area is tricky to see, but I'll try to explain it as best I can. The two bottom long rows are the 2-space doors and walls, the broken walls in the first well and doors in the next. Above them, the same is true for the single doors and walls. Doors are first while broken walls are next. All the other tiles fit in the rest of the section. The key is to group 'like' tiles together (ex. Norad character and decoy tokens together, same for Salemite, Norad radio jamming tokens together, same for Salemite, etc.) If you keep 'like' groups together, they fit nicely in the wells. Finally, the remaining order tiles fit on the right side.

Top left and moving right again. The T-tiles on top of the large room tile. 12-space rectangle tiles top right. Bottom left, the 3-space L-tiles and 5-space L-tile on alternate corners. I moved one of the 3-space L-tiles to keep the top flush (there are 4 small L-tiles and only 2 large L-tiles). The 5-space long tiles are next along with the 6-space rectangle tiles below them. Finally the Comm Room goes on top of the smaller tiles.

The huge 7-space L-tile on top of the T-tiles. I put the dice on top of the cards. The + tiles in the bottom left. The rest of the long 4- and 3-space tiles on top of the 5-space one.

Character tokens top left. The wound/CP tokens on top of the dice. The border tiles bottom left. The cloth bag, bag with the initiative, on/off, and player tokens, and the remaining plastic bags bottom right.

The player boards go 2 on each side, if you examine the container, you will see the shelves that are there hold them perfectly.

Anyway, those are my 2 cents on the correct box set-up. Hope it helps!!

Side note, it appears the Salemite’s discovered Cherokee Bill was a traitor before the box was opened and decided to perform an emergency amputation (see below).

Who would be the best person to talk to about a possible replacement? Would it be here at Ludically, or should I speak with Zev at Z-man? Thanks for the help!!